What was Steve Gaines really saying here?Photo © Commercial Appeal 2009
This week the Shelby County Board of Commissioners considered an ordinance that would prohibit discrimination against gay and transgender employees. The same rules would apply to contractors who do work for the county as well as private businesses in unincorporated areas of Shelby County. Alliances of disparate groups formed quickly, and their protests were loud.
County ordinance targets discrimination against gay, transgender people
On Tuesday, May 26th, a group of local pastors and protestors on both sides met for a news conference in front of the Shelby County administrative building.
Memphis pastors, county commissioner speak against anti-discrimination measure
Video
In a vote the following day the proposed ordinance did not receive a deciding vote with the vote split 5-5 with two abstentions. The proposal will be read before the full commission on Monday where it must pass three readings to become law.
Anti-discrimination policy fails to gain majority support in Shelby committee
In a surprising classic example of politics making strange bedfellows, Steve Gaines was a guest on Thaddeus Matthews' radio program Tuesday afternoon. Thaddeus Matthews, for the uninformed, hosts a talk radio program on AM 990 KWAM in Memphis. No stranger to controversy, the foul-mouthed, seemingly sex-obsessed Matthews does not mind taking on many controversial subjects. To his credit he's exposed a lot of the corruption in Memphis and Shelby County government some of the local black churches.
Then he made headlines last year when he posted autopsy photos of one of the victims of the Lester Street murders on his blog. (Warning: Content, particularly in the comment threads, is likely to be offensive!)
Postmortem photos draw ire
I had never listened to Matthews' radio show until reviewing Tuesday's broadcast. I listened to most of it live Wednesday. I can only describe the man as a cross between Rush Limbaugh, Mark Driscoll, Eddie Murphy, and Charles Barkley -- loud, obnoxious, opinionated, and, I have to admit, often right. He spent the better part of Wednesday's show talking with callers about rumors regarding the sexual orientation of a number of local black pastors and church musicians as well as a lively and graphic discussion of oral sex and homosexual acts. Then he preached a little in the last hour, actually making some good points -- interspersed with a few more expletives. That's why the guy is such a enigma. He's not stupid. He says what he thinks, and he sticks with his position and defends it well, but after listening to him you experience an overwhelming need to take a shower and wash your ears out with soap.
You can listen to Steve Gaines' interview with Thaddeus Matthews here. (May take a while to load. The interview begins at 4:50 if you want to skip ahead.) There's a rather disgusting conversation between Matthews and a female caller at the beginning (which will give you a good idea of the caliber of his program and many of his callers), then the interview with Pastor Gaines in which Gaines defends his position thoughtfully and clearly, followed by some closing commentary by Matthews and a commercial that I think you'll find worth the wait.
I'm going to assume Steve Gaines has never listened to Matthews' radio program or read his blog.



Note: For those of you searching for information on Jamie Parker (and you are legion), Jamie was the minister of music at First Baptist Church, Dyersburg, TN for a little over a year after he left Bellevue. (Apparently they don't ever update their website.)
As of January 1, 2011 he's at Cross Church (Ronnie Floyd) in Springdale, Arkansas. Watch.
It was learned this week that Minister of Music Jamie Parker is among the latest casualties left in Steve Gaines' wake. Without going into great detail (because no one but the parties involved knows all the details and that is not the purpose of this post) Jamie was reportedly informed by Steve Gaines in late March that he needed to seek other employment, but apparently it was understood he would be allowed to remain for a while until he could find another position. It was thought Sunday would be his last day, but that apparently changed.
The only question I have is what happened to that "covenant relationship" that Steve has stated he has with Jamie... the assurance that wherever Steve is, Jamie will always have a place? Steve brought Jamie from Gardendale with the promise of a secure future here. Jamie and Dana bought a large, beautiful home on several acres of land in the country thinking Jamie would eventually retire from Bellevue. Now they're stuck during the worst economic times in decades with a big mortgage and an uncertain immediate future.
It's no secret a lot of people were disappointed at the way Jim Whitmire was forced to "retire" when Steve Gaines came. No doubt that situation could have been handled a lot differently and much better than it was. Some said Jim was tired and needed to take it easy. So tired, I suppose, that when he left Bellevue he spent several months flying back and forth to Dallas every weekend to serve as interim minister of music at FBC Dallas, then took the full-time minister of music position at GBC, and now serves as full-time minister of music at FBC Jax. But life goes on.
Jamie came in January 2006 amid much fanfare and immediately made some changes in the music program which were unpopular with some. However, he seemed to hit his stride after a while and seemed to hit a happy medium with most people. In my opinion, Jamie is now being thrown under the bus, just like many fine staff members before him.
I think a lot of people saw this coming when Mark Blair was brought on board to handle "special productions." Then Mark was given even more responsibilities as evidenced by this letter sent to the choir. I take no satisfaction in the fact I predicted this outcome six months ago. Almost two years ago we learned Steve Gaines was trying to blame the declining attendance numbers on the music. Then Jamie and the music department took the fall for the infamous dance routine. Ryan Wingo and his trademark guitar have been increasingly "front and center" in worship services.
There is no doubt Jamie Parker loves the Lord, is very talented, and God has a better place for him. Dana, with her beautiful voice and sweet spirit has been an asset to the church and choir and will no doubt be a source of strength and support to Jamie during these uncertain days.
To Jamie and Dana, I wish you all the best and want you to always remember that "all things work together for good to them that love God, to them who are the called according to his purpose." It probably doesn't feel like it right now, but God has bigger things for you than Bellevue. Take your talent, that winning smile, and those big dimples and go... serve... Him! Remember that men will always disappoint you but God never will. Stay strong and always stay faithful. God has great things in store for you both!
Who can forget this?
On this blog:
We want to minister to everybody...Who's really the sociopath here?
This is the "Biblical Pattern" for Church Discipline?
Some Thoughts on "Church Authority" and "Church Discipline"
Jacksonville, FL Church Cover-up - Déjà Vu, Bellevue?
Florida Times-Union:
Phil Fretz > Blogger in church tussle can't have it both ways
Mark Woods > First Baptist blogger case where it should be: In judge's handsTelevision coverage:
First Coast News > Internet Blog on First Baptist Church Causes StirFOX 30 > Sheriff Rutherford Responds To Church Intelligence Investigation
Tiffany Croft's blog:
Here is the latest story regarding this blog and the investigation
Stop Baptist Predators:
Go Dog Go!FBC-Jax: "Big Brother meets Big Church"
Mac Brunson on Gilyard & Patterson
Baptist Life Forums:
Blogger sues after Jacksonville cops out him to FBC Jax
Brunson re: blogger "sociopath...obsessive compulsive"
Church discipline according to FBCJax
FBC Jax Calls for Sever of Ties to Lifeway Over The Shack
Wade Burleson's blog:
A Southern Baptist Religious "State of Play"
We Are As Healthy As The Secrets We Keep
Censure, Censorship, and Church Citizenship
Abuse of Authority: It Must Not Be Ignored
The High Cost of Stifling Criticism and Dissent
Your Honor, Please Help Us Understand
Anonymous Writing Is Not Intrinsically Evil
Lessons in Dealing with a Disgruntled Church Member
The Untouchables: Spiritually Elite Leaders and the Unwillingness to Be Held Accountable
From around the world:
ABP News > Authorities expose blogger who has been hounding FBC Jacksonville
Anonymous Blogger Gets Outed then Booted From His Church!
Anonymous Blogger Messes with Church... Church messes back...Baptist Planet > Fbc Jax posts
Bene Diction Blogs On > SBC Jax Watchblog update
Bene Diction Blogs On > Whereas... the FBC Jax Watchdog blog
Bene Diction Blogs On > Whereas, First Baptist Church Jacksonville and law enforcement
Christian School Confidential > to the bloggers of Jacksonville
Daily Kos > FL megachurch security detail/sheriff's dept unmasks blogger's ID
Debbie Kaufman > Enough Is Enough
Deep Thoughts > Where is the love?
ExChristian.net > Church pulls strings in an attempt to muzzle a blogger critical of the leadership
First Baptist Church of Jacksonville Florida: Snakes and Vipers
First Baptist downtown votes out supposed blogger
Forums > Law enforcement exposes blogger for pastor after revealing salary
Google Helps Identify Anonymous Blogger
Holy Man of the Day: Pastor Mac Brunson
Jacksonville First Baptist Has Police Out Anonymous Blogger
JaxOutLoud Forum > First Baptist Church and the Internet
JONATHAN TURLEY > Baptist Church Accused of Using Florida Detective to Uncover and Identify Critical BloggerLegal Schnauzer > Blogger Draws the Ire of a Southern Mega-Church
Mainline Disease and the Southern Baptists
Megachurch Uses Police to Out Critical Blogger's Identity
Metro Jacksonville > Unmasked blogger blames First Baptist, Sheriff's Office
my TPM blog > And yet again -- another blogger outing
On my soapbox RE: FBC Downtown
* Outed Blogger Sues Sheriff's Department
Science Blog > Pharyngula > Mac Brunson, Baptist tyrant and greedy Pharisee
The Big Daddy Weave > Megachurch Passes Resolution Against Blogger
The Mudflats > Jacksonville Florida First Baptist Church Outs Anonymous Blogger!!
Unmasked blogger blames First Baptist, Sheriff's Office
UPI > Blogger: Detective gave his ID to church
WebProNews > Google Helps Identify Anonymous Blogger
Women In Ministry > Reaching unity in the faith without authoritarian control
And of course the FBC Jax Watchdog blog itself.
* Recently added
Thanks to "Thy Peace" for this exhaustive list!
New links will continue to be added periodically.